NARS Creamy Concealer vs. Urban Decay Naked Skin Concealer

NARS Creamy Concealer in Chantilly, Vanilla vs Urban Decay Naked Skin Concealer in Fair Neutral - Review, comparison and swatchesPeople have been going crazy for the Urban Decay Naked Skin Concealer. And for good reason too, I knew I had to have it as soon as Jaclyn Hill declared her love for it so I grabbed it while I was in the U.S. Nowadays, it’s hard to come by due to UD changing the formula around, only adding to the hype now that’s more exclusive. I’ve been loving it for for a couple of months now but I’ve been having more and more people ask what I thought of it compared to another favourite of mine, the NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer, so I thought it was worth wrapping up all of my thoughts in one post.

NARS Creamy Concealer in Chantilly, Vanilla vs Urban Decay Naked Skin Concealer in Fair Neutral - Review, comparison and swatches

When it comes to packaging, both are pretty and practical. Both have a sponge-y applicator but they’re vastly different in design. The NARS offering has the standard doefoot applicator. It picks up a bit of product and distributes it nicely but it is quite stiff which means it can be a tiny bit harsh if you’re using it on delicate skin, such as around your eyes. The Urban Decay concealer has a longer, flat applicator which is really bendy and makes it easy to spread the product. I much prefer the UD applicator – each side of the applicator picks up just the right amount of product for me to use under my eyes so it’s super handy.

In the UD concealer, I go for the shade Fair Neutral, the lightest from the range. In the NARS range, I have two different shades, Chantilly and Vanilla, again, the two lightest from the range. I use Chantilly for under eye highlighting and Vanilla for blemishes, as I’ve spoken about before. Fair Neutral and Chantilly are fairly close matches to each other, Fair Neutral is slightly lighter and pinker. The UD range has eight shades and the NARS range has ten which means that technically, you’re slightly more likely to find a match at the NARS stand.

NARS Creamy Concealer in Chantilly, Vanilla vs Urban Decay Naked Skin Concealer in Fair Neutral - Review, comparison and swatchesL to R: NARS Chantilly, NARS Vanilla, Urban Decay Fair Neutral.

But formula’s what really counts, hey? And that’s where it gets a little harder to tell them apart. Both are thin yet creamy concealers that pack a punch when it comes to pigment. I find that the Urban Decay concealer is a little thinner and easier to blend in to the skin than the NARS concealer, which can often take a bit of warming up and messing about with before it’ll start looking natural on the skin. Both wear well throughout the day with no creasing under the eyes. The NARS Creamy Concealer is slightly more likely to flake up on dry patches and blemishes due to it being a little thicker.

Overall, I’ve noticed that since the Urban Decay concealer came home with me, the NARS Creamy Concealers have been sitting unloved in my drawers. The Urban Decay one is just so foolproof and easy to use, it’s particularly fond of the BeautyBlender, too. So it’s been on daily rotation under the eyes. It’s even slightly cheaper than the NARS offering! Needless to say, Urban Decay has knocked NARS out of it’s top spot in my concealer collection.
Have you tried either of these concealers? Which would you pick?

Bloglovin | Instagram | Twitter | Pinterest


*this post contains affiliate links

  • This is such a helpful review! I was trying decide which of these to pick up & was leaning towards UD, the colour looks a lot less yellow compared to NARS too 🙂

  • The Sunday Mode

    I have the Nars concealer and I’m always wondering whether or not I should stray and try out the UD one. I wonder if the UD concealer still trumps Nars in the spot concealing department?

  • So much hype around the UD concealer! I’m definitely going to pick it up once I finish my Maybelline fit me concealer – which is soon! As much as I love the NARS, I kinda hate when it accentuated flaky/dry skin, which always tends to be around blemishes which is what I’m trying to cover up!

    Tasha // shiwashiful.

    • I wish I had the power to use up one product before buying another! hahah. Yeah, I agree – the flakiness was too annoying on the dry skin.

  • Oooo intersting! Great comparison 🙂 I haven’t tried either but definitely need to pick up the Urban Decay.

    Sarah | More Than Adored

  • I haven’t tried UD one but Nars one is really good. After this review I definitely want to try out UD. xx

  • Rebecca

    I’ve been using my UD Naked Skin concealer daily, I am obsessed. I am yet to test it against my other fave MAC Pro Longwear but I already prefer the applicator 🙂
    Beauty Wanderer

    • It’s been used just about daily by me too! The applicator is much easier to use than MAC’s Pro Longwear!

  • Ahh I’ve been meaning to compare these too! I never thought it would happen, but my NARS concealers have also been gathering dust. UD all the way! x

    Daniela |

    • I know, it’s crazy to think that they’re feeling so unloved right now! My Vanilla is just about empty but I don’t think I’ll be picking up another…

  • I do notice that the NARS concealer tends to look a bit dry and cakey under my eyes, so would love to try the UD naked one! It sounds awesome :O

    Sheri | Behind The Frames

  • Alinta

    I still can’t decide which one to get